Why Most Sales Teams Struggle to Realize AI Productivity Gains

Victoria Myers
June 5, 2025
See the future of AI-Powered Selling
Get a demo

Introduction

AI has been pitched as the answer to every sales leader’s productivity problem. But despite unprecedented investment in tools and tech, most sellers today are still stuck in the same grind—juggling CRM hygiene, stakeholder mapping, internal follow-ups, and endless admin.

The result? AI fatigue. GenAI pilots that overpromise and underdeliver. Reps who spend more time wrangling tools than closing deals.

This post unpacks why most sales AI strategies fall short—and why unifying your sales process under a single agentic interface is the key to actually seeing productivity lift.

The Productivity Promise, Broken

Sellers Aren’t Selling

According to Pavilion's 2025 GTM Benchmarks Report, the average seller spends just 2 hours a day in active selling, while top performers at AI-enabled companies spend twice as much time with customers. It's still half a day max. Research from Salesforce supports this, finding that 70% of seller time is spent on non-customer-facing work.

So what’s stopping everyone?

Manual tasks and disjointed tooling. In fact, 70% of sellers say they’re overwhelmed by the number of sales tools they’re expected to use—a 19% increase since 2022 (Gartner).

Instead of streamlining work, many AI deployments have introduced a new kind of chaos: toggle tax, tool fatigue, and orphaned insights that live in isolated copilots.

AI Fragmentation is the Enemy of Productivity

AI Tools That Don’t Talk to Each Other Can’t Help Sellers Sell

GTM teams are often lured into a web of point solutions: one tool for emails, another for notes, another for stakeholder intel. Each tool adds friction—and none of them work in concert.

This fractured experience forces reps to orchestrate their own workflows across disconnected AI layers, defeating the very purpose of automation. Or it leaves revenue operations teams and leaders managing complex multi-agent architectures.

Orchestration Is Now the Hidden Tax on Sales Teams

The average seller now interacts with 10+ apps per deal, and most organizations are spending more on integration and enablement than they are seeing in productivity gains. It’s no surprise that 78% of sellers missed quota in 2024, up from 69% the year before.

A New Path Forward: From Tool Chaos to Contextual Intelligence

AI That Understands the Whole Deal, Not Just the Last Task

The biggest barrier to AI impact is fragmentation. Sellers toggle between disconnected tools that each know a sliver of the deal, but none that understand the full picture: product fit, buyer priorities, objection history, and what’s already been promised. Vendors muddy the water by marketing automated static workflows and LLM-wrapped chatbots as genuine "agentic" solutions - a phenomenon Gartner calls "Agent-Washing."

Top-performing teams are solving this with a different approach—not more tools, but centralized intelligence. Instead of relying on task-level copilots, they’re investing in intelligent, multi-functional, proactive AI Sales Agents that can:

  • Auto-generate solution briefs mapped to specific buyer pain
  • Maintain up-to-date stakeholder maps as conversations evolve
  • Detect deal risk and expansion signals without being prompted
  • Assemble post-sale documentation without additional lift from the rep

This shift transforms AI from a collection of assistants into a true partner in the deal. Sellers spend less time re-entering data, explaining context, or stitching together outputs—and more time actually selling.

The result: more velocity, less orchestration, and a compounding productivity advantage (see the Financial Impact guide here).

Benchmarking Against the Best

Let’s ground this with hard data from the 2025 GTM Benchmarks Report.

Only 14% of Sellers Drive 80% of Revenue
A staggering 11x productivity gap exists between top and average performers, driven by better discovery, stakeholder engagement, and deal velocity.

Top Performers:

  • Engage decision-makers early (win rates jump 55%)
  • Avoid late-stage slippage (reducing revenue leaks up to 113%)
  • Multi-thread and manage 164% more pipeline than B-players
  • Spend 2x more time in live selling conversations

Where AI Makes the Difference

Among top-performing teams, 88% use AI primarily to eliminate manual tasks—not just to write emails, but to reduce the admin tax across discovery, value storytelling, and post-sales prep.

But this only works when AI is centralized and contextual. Tools without deal awareness can’t generate insights that actually matter.

The Data Layer Is the Final Frontier

Here’s the kicker: 44% of contacts never make it into CRM, and 26% of those are decision-makers. AI can't operate at full power if it’s fed broken or incomplete data.

That’s why productivity-focused organizations are investing in infrastructure that automatically captures and unifies deal signals—giving AI a complete, accurate foundation to act on.

FAQs

Why haven’t most AI deployments improved sales productivity?

Because they’re layered on top of fragmented workflows, forcing sellers to act as orchestrators rather than closers. Productivity gains require unified intelligence and a single UI for reps, not piecemeal point solutions.

What separates high-performing sales orgs using AI from everyone else?

They prioritize context and convenience. Rather than just adding more tools, they adopt AI systems that understand the full deal lifecycle and proactively support it end-to-end.

How does a unifed agentic experience improve seller efficiency?

It eliminates manual prep (solution docs, stakeholder maps, value recaps), surfaces risks automatically, and cuts the toggle tax that comes from bouncing between disconnected tools.

Conclusion: Productivity Is Power—But Only When AI Works Together

AI hasn’t failed sales teams. Sales teams have been failed by fragmented, hype-driven point solutions that promise productivity while delivering only complexity.

The future isn’t about more tools. It’s about giving sellers more power—with AI that works the way they do: holistically, intelligently, and always in context.